TimeTechTalk.com Home


Welcome to 3T! Please take the time to register and join in on the friendly,knowledgeable watch talk.Please note that not all registrations will receive an immediate activation e-mail.Those who do not receive an immediate notification will be activated manually within 48hrs. by an admin. without an e-mail activation url sent to you,you may then sign in using your username and password,if you feel there is a problem please e-mail us at timetechtalk@hotmail.com and include your name and username and we activate your account.Thank You!

 Moderated by: 3T  
AuthorPost
mjl4321
3T WIS


Joined: Sun Aug 5th, 2007
Location: San Diego, California USA
Posts: 43
Status: 
Offline
I am keen to get other folks opinion on this....

When I started collecting watches, I set myself some rules about what would go into my collection.  My main rules were:

Rule 1: only watches that have a significant emotional impact on me (and others), that I would wear on a regular basis (not watches that are valuable to the market but not wearable by me....I am not a speculator or trader)
Rule 2: nothing less than 40mm case size
Rule 3: nothing goes out (I have never sold a watch - only a significant change in my financial situation or what 'does it for me' would force me to sell something)
Rule 4: no quartz movements (this is connected to craftmanship, the need for care, uniqueness etc.)

So far I have been able to expand my collection happily and stay within these 'rules'.  But..........I am increasingly finding that there are watches that meet Rules 1 & 2 but violate Rule 4! :shock:  Actually it was Mark's Ocean7 G-2 :cool: over on 'New Arrivals' that finally prompted me to seriously question Rule No. 4.

I am guessing that most people are guided most by somethign like my Rule 1, but I would be really interested in other people's collecting 'rules' and specifically.....give me some arguments to help me convince myself that 'quartz is OK' .........so that I can buy a G-2!

sjedwardz
3T WIS


Joined: Wed Jun 6th, 2007
Location:  
Posts: 37
Status: 
Offline
If you only dated blondes and Angelina Jolie called you up would you give her the elbowmistake.gif


Looking at your rules you've seen to priotise them, I've got very similar buying crieteria but haven't written them down!

Most of my watches are mechanical because that's what I like but I do have a few quartz. Must say its rather nice just to put one on and not have to set the date/timerev_smile.gif


I think if you like it buy it - nothing wrong with quartz thats just the engine. Audi won Le Mans with a diesel car - I wouldn't turn one of those down even though I'm a petrol head.

mjl4321
3T WIS


Joined: Sun Aug 5th, 2007
Location: San Diego, California USA
Posts: 43
Status: 
Offline
Great first post here on 3T!  I particularly like the way you managed to get women and cars into the response yourock.gif

sjedwardz wrote:
If you only dated blondes and Angelina Jolie called you up would you give her the elbowmistake.gif


Looking at your rules you've seen to priotise them, I've got very similar buying crieteria but haven't written them down!

Most of my watches are mechanical because that's what I like but I do have a few quartz. Must say its rather nice just to put one on and not have to set the date/timerev_smile.gif


I think if you like it buy it - nothing wrong with quartz thats just the engine. Audi won Le Mans with a diesel car - I wouldn't turn one of those down even though I'm a petrol head.


sjedwardz
3T WIS


Joined: Wed Jun 6th, 2007
Location:  
Posts: 37
Status: 
Offline
Damm - forgot beer!

Skipdawg
3T WIS


Joined: Thu Mar 29th, 2007
Location: Washington USA
Posts: 14965
Status: 
Offline
Over the years I have changed some. In the 1990's I mostly bought quartz watches. Have sold or traded off most all of those now. Have a handful left. :)

Mostly buy Automatics now. Do have some manual wind and some solar powered ones too. ;)

After a while I just got tired of changing batteries. LOL :D

MarkJnK
3T WIS


Joined: Sun Apr 15th, 2007
Location: Ontario Canada
Posts: 275
Status: 
Offline
My buying criteria is similar to yours except that rule #3 falls victim to rule#1.  I can't determine if a watch meets the criteria of rule #1 until I have it in hand and live with it for a month or so (or an hour sometimes).  If it doesn't live up to my expectations, out it goes to make room for another.  I try to keep my collection to 10ish watches and only pieces that I will wear and enjoy.  No drawer queens.  If a watch gets overlooked for a couple weeks or a month, the thrill is gone and out it goes.

While I don't have a "no quartz" rule, my collection is 10ish autos, 1 ecodrive, 1 kinetic, and one quartz, so I'm definitely in the auto camp.  But the G2 evoked an emotion in me that I couldn't suppress.  It is simply an awesome looking piece with a stellar case and bracelet at a killer price.  I also agree that it is nice sometimes to just grab a watch and throw it on without winding or setting the time.  A "lazy day" watch.

Sorry that my G-2 post is causing you such turmoil :P

mcwright
Admin


Joined: Wed Sep 28th, 2005
Location: SCOTTSDALE, AZ
Posts: 4759
Status: 
Offline
I have a six or so Quartz watches. If you get a good watch with a battery life rated at 3-5 years, you won't be changing that often. And, there are a number of watches with 10 year batteries (lithium, I believe).

Really cheap quartz watches tend to have batteries that crap out after a year or so.

Scuba Steve
3T WIS


Joined: Fri Jun 22nd, 2007
Location: Gonzales, Louisiana USA
Posts: 592
Status: 
Offline
I prefer autos over anything else but I do not have a no quartz rule. In fact there is one quartz watch I want very much, the original Bathy's UV model but I will never give what everyone wants for them so I probably will never own one.

mjl4321
3T WIS


Joined: Sun Aug 5th, 2007
Location: San Diego, California USA
Posts: 43
Status: 
Offline
OK, so it's true. I am a movement snob after all!  I have been denying myself all these years! 

So, it's off to O7 for me......and then maybe that green Wenger diver.......and then maybe.....
.......a whole new world of purchasing options cool10.gif
!

Eric L.
3T WIS


Joined: Thu Feb 15th, 2007
Location:  
Posts: 386
Status: 
Offline
 I had the no quartz rule as well (except for the Eco-Drive I keep around to set the automatics to), and whenever I violated it, I found myself flipping the watch soon afterwards - even if it has nothing to do with the sophistication of the movement, I feel that I am giving something to the automatic since it gets wound as I wear it - i.e. my wearing it makes a difference.  With the quartz, whether I wear it or keep it in the case for six months, it doesn't matter, and that kind of popped the balloon on my interest level.

Nowadays when I see quartz on a pricey watch, I think it either must have a crazy dive rating, or I don't even look at it - think about how much extra an ETA 2824-2 would cost?  I think Borel and Ofrei have them for a little over $100  Small price to pay (on the part of the watch manufacturer) for a huge difference in perception of the watch for nuts like us.

canadajo
3T WIS


Joined: Sun Jun 11th, 2006
Location: Packerland, Wisconsin USA
Posts: 3360
Status: 
Offline
Recently in new arrivals I posted a Wenger 1000 meter diver with a green bezel .....and I explained in the post I own 50 or 60 and out of all them I only have 3 quartz but I like those three ... that Wenger only cost me 180 dollars and it kicks ass ....the others are a Formex Chrono and a echo drive promaster ....In watch collecting I stay usually with ETA based Swiss divers but there are too many rules in life as it is ....I like Skips analogy with blonds and such

Chick Hazzard
3T WIS


Joined: Sat Apr 7th, 2007
Location: Huntington Beach, California USA
Posts: 680
Status: 
Offline
I usually buy what ever I like, quartz/auto/hand wound, as long as I can afford it. I thought I would never sell a watch, but now when I see something I want, I have no problem selling a watch that I don't wear very often to buy a new one.
Just do what makes you happy.

Eeeb
3T WIS


Joined: Sat Jun 30th, 2007
Location: Cowlumbus, Ohio USA
Posts: 30
Status: 
Offline
mjl4321 wrote: OK, so it's true. I am a movement snob after all!  I have been denying myself all these years! 

So, it's off to O7 for me......and then maybe that green Wenger diver.......and then maybe.....
.......a whole new world of purchasing options cool10.gif
!



I'm a movement snob too... Indeed, while I don't share your love of big watches, your rules are largely my rules with the exception of no quartz. 

I have a number of ETA 205.111|711|911 Autoquartz watches - from solid 14kt to cheap Swatches -- they are automatics and quartzes with highly jeweled movements.  Fun as most have transparent backs.

And I have several thermocompensated ETA movements - you can adjust them yourself and end up with a watch that is accurate to 1 second a year.  Again, fun.

Mechanicals are fun too -- most of mine are mechanicals and my latest buy was a NOS 1960 Tissot with a pristine 14kt case.  But a good quartz can be just as interesting.  Don't count them out just because most are 'throwaways' -- some aren't!

I don't know if anyone has noticed -- my icon is the first mechanical movement timed by quartz.  The batteries were replaced by an automatic movement that charged a capacitor... It's the HPM from Asulab (Swatch Research). It was developed about 15 years ago... Now that's fun too!  woohoo.gif  (The closest I can get to having one is the Autoquartzs...  I can't bring myself to pay Seiko's price for their copy, the Spring Drive.)

jsb806f
Guest
 

Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 
Status: 
Offline
I have noticied a bit of movement elitism since I joined the forum. One reason I stopped posting to the "new arivals" section is the inevtiable, "yes, but it's only a quartz movement" comment. I am now trading off many of my automatics because I'm tired of having to reset my automatics before I put them on the wrist. Yes, I do have six auto winders but that too is a bit of a pain as well. I'll put my Omega Seamaster (yes, it's only a quartz) up against your automatic Seamaster any day. I can deal with the hassle of replacing a battery every couple of years for the accuracy and convenience of my quartz.

The only relevant criteria are (1) do YOU like it and (b) can you afford it? I frequently violate the second criteria much to my wife's dismay. I just got a $99 Sthurling Pilot quartz movement that I like, enjoy and wear more than several watches costing 20 times more.
It isn't a question of right/wrong good/bad. Maybe you don't prefer a quartz movement but some of us do. There's more than enough room for both kinds of movements.

Last edited on Fri Aug 17th, 2007 10:44 am by

mjl4321
3T WIS


Joined: Sun Aug 5th, 2007
Location: San Diego, California USA
Posts: 43
Status: 
Offline
Funny you should say that....one of the reasons I started to question my own 'elitism' was that posts here regarding new quartz arrivals were NOT getting that kind of response.  

You make a really good point about the 'wife factor'.......One thing that I hadn't thought about that will finally swing it for me is that relaxing my 'no quartz' rule is certainly going to make my wife happier! hearteyes.gif  (well until she realizes that while the price of each one might be lower, the USPS guy is coming more frequently!!!)

jsb806f wrote:
I have noticied a bit of movement elitism since I joined the forum. One reason I stopped posting to the "new arivals" section is the inevtiable, "yes, but it's only a quartz movement" comment. I am now trading off many of my automatics because I'm tired of having to reset my automatics before I put them on the wrist. Yes, I do have six auto winders but that too is a bit of a pain as well. I'll put my Omega Seamaster (yes, it's only a quartz) up against your automatic Seamaster any day. I can deal with the hassle of replacing a battery every couple of years for the accuracy and convenience of my quartz.

The only relevant criteria are (1) do YOU like it and (b) can you afford it? I frequently violate the second criteria much to my wife's dismay. I just got a $99 Sthurling Pilot quartz movement that I like, enjoy and wear more than several watches costing 20 times more.
It isn't a question of right/wrong good/bad. Maybe you don't prefer a quartz movement but some of us do. There's more than enough room for both kinds of movements.


canadajo
3T WIS


Joined: Sun Jun 11th, 2006
Location: Packerland, Wisconsin USA
Posts: 3360
Status: 
Offline
Buy what one likes and enjoys ... there is room enough for all makes and movements ....I love my Wenger 1000 meter quartz that I recently posted in new arrivals ....  but I am interested in horology and its history and there were no quartz's back even in my dad's day and there is beauty in an automatics movement also ....anyone who sneers at a watch that somebody buys and likes is an a-hole

zippofan
3T WIS


Joined: Tue Feb 6th, 2007
Location: Scranton, Pennsylvania USA
Posts: 2408
Status: 
Offline
I'll say ditto on buy what you like.  One of my favorites is a Seiko quartz chronograph, the SNA225.  It is nicely finished for the price, and the alarm movement can be used as that or a second time zone.  Plus the chrono hand moves in 1/5 sec steps that mimic a mechanical, cool :D
Most of my watches now are autos or hand crankers, but I have a watch box full of quartz that are my go to's when I am in a hurry and don't have time to set an auto, or when I have a gig and I use my G-Shock (I play drums).

Cheers,
Griff

mjl4321
3T WIS


Joined: Sun Aug 5th, 2007
Location: San Diego, California USA
Posts: 43
Status: 
Offline
Guys, don't get me wrong here.  I've never questioned why others buy quartz watches and would certainly never sneer.  It's just never been for me....until yesterday.  Have added 4 quartz watches to my want list and one of them is at the top....that G-2........


canadajo wrote:
Buy what one likes and enjoys ... there is room enough for all makes and movements ....I love my Wenger 1000 meter quartz that I recently posted in new arrivals ....  but I am interested in horology and its history and there were no quartz's back even in my dad's day and there is beauty in an automatics movement also ....anyone who sneers at a watch that somebody buys and likes is an a-hole

jsb806f
Guest
 

Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 
Status: 
Offline
You aren't being critical of quartz movements . . . but you did raise the issue or opened up this can-o-worms.

toon1.gif

canadajo
3T WIS


Joined: Sun Jun 11th, 2006
Location: Packerland, Wisconsin USA
Posts: 3360
Status: 
Offline
YOU DIDNT SNEER .....in fact I thought you were concidering a quartz purchace ...no worries dude   happy1.gif

mjl4321 wrote:
Guys, don't get me wrong here.  I've never questioned why others buy quartz watches and would certainly never sneer.  It's just never been for me....until yesterday.  Have added 4 quartz watches to my want list and one of them is at the top....that G-2........


canadajo wrote:
Buy what one likes and enjoys ... there is room enough for all makes and movements ....I love my Wenger 1000 meter quartz that I recently posted in new arrivals ....  but I am interested in horology and its history and there were no quartz's back even in my dad's day and there is beauty in an automatics movement also ....anyone who sneers at a watch that somebody buys and likes is an a-hole

mjl4321
3T WIS


Joined: Sun Aug 5th, 2007
Location: San Diego, California USA
Posts: 43
Status: 
Offline
That Wenger 1000m could actually be my first.....love the green bezel and silver dial.

canadajo wrote:
YOU DIDNT SNEER .....in fact I thought you were concidering a quartz purchace ...no worries dude   happy1.gif

mjl4321 wrote:
Guys, don't get me wrong here.  I've never questioned why others buy quartz watches and would certainly never sneer.  It's just never been for me....until yesterday.  Have added 4 quartz watches to my want list and one of them is at the top....that G-2........


canadajo wrote:
Buy what one likes and enjoys ... there is room enough for all makes and movements ....I love my Wenger 1000 meter quartz that I recently posted in new arrivals ....  but I am interested in horology and its history and there were no quartz's back even in my dad's day and there is beauty in an automatics movement also ....anyone who sneers at a watch that somebody buys and likes is an a-hole


DEMO
Guest
 

Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 
Status: 
Offline
I agree, buy what you like and what makes you happy (and what you can afford). That is what our hobby is all about. Most of my watches are mechanical, I just find mechanical movements fascinating. But that does not mean I don't like a good quartz time piece. Heck, I have several quartz powered pieces in the collection. I have 2 Sector 600 dive chronos





Both excellent watches. Quality is great and both super accurate. I also just purchased an Ocean 7 G-2. Also a great watch with it's swiss Ronda 5030.D movement. As a WIS, collect and wear what makes you happy. :D

Dave

MarkJnK
3T WIS


Joined: Sun Apr 15th, 2007
Location: Ontario Canada
Posts: 275
Status: 
Offline
Soooooo mjl4321, did you order the G-2 before the coupon disappears?

Just to tease you again...

Attachment: Ocean7 G-2.jpg (Downloaded 55 times)

srh_pres
3T WIS


Joined: Wed Nov 15th, 2006
Location: Orlando, Florida USA
Posts: 6057
Status: 
Offline
Great shot of the G-2 Mark...hand6.gif

MarkJnK wrote:
Soooooo mjl4321, did you order the G-2 before the coupon disappears?

Just to tease you again...

e.avery
3T WIS


Joined: Tue Apr 4th, 2006
Location: Kentucky USA
Posts: 2722
Status: 
Offline
I purchase what I like, or what works given the operational conditions.

I purchase watches to mark events.  I purchase sets in order to build relationships between team members and to help build relationships between people that have little in common.

I live my life under one rule if you can have anything in life what would it be?  For me it is a $40 Victorinox chrono., Orient day date diver, or a Seiko.

mjl4321
3T WIS


Joined: Sun Aug 5th, 2007
Location: San Diego, California USA
Posts: 43
Status: 
Offline
Where's the coupon?  Couldn't see it.

Might be tricky since I just told my wife about the Blue Monstrum and PloProf pre-orders ;-)

But a coupon....now that would help.

Mike


MarkJnK wrote: Soooooo mjl4321, did you order the G-2 before the coupon disappears?

Just to tease you again...

NANDO-FERDZ
3T WIS


Joined: Thu Jul 6th, 2006
Location: California USA
Posts: 358
Status: 
Offline
Every WIS individual has different set of rules in buying watches. And here are my five basic rules in buying a watch.

 
1. Automatic/Manual winding(prefarably swiss ETA based movement)


2. Brushed/satin finished case

3. Not less than 40mm in case diameter

4. Sapphire crystal

5. And it should be within my price range


I used to own some QUARTZ watches(mostly CHRONO) and other watches that do not fall into these criteria and ended up selling them all. So, now I am trying to strictly follow these rules to avoid losing $:(


Good luck on your decision...


 

 

mjl4321 wrote:
I am keen to get other folks opinion on this....

When I started collecting watches, I set myself some rules about what would go into my collection.  My main rules were:

Rule 1: only watches that have a significant emotional impact on me (and others), that I would wear on a regular basis (not watches that are valuable to the market but not wearable by me....I am not a speculator or trader)
Rule 2: nothing less than 40mm case size
Rule 3: nothing goes out (I have never sold a watch - only a significant change in my financial situation or what 'does it for me' would force me to sell something)
Rule 4: no quartz movements (this is connected to craftmanship, the need for care, uniqueness etc.)

So far I have been able to expand my collection happily and stay within these 'rules'.  But..........I am increasingly finding that there are watches that meet Rules 1 & 2 but violate Rule 4! :shock:  Actually it was Mark's Ocean7 G-2 :cool: over on 'New Arrivals' that finally prompted me to seriously question Rule No. 4.

I am guessing that most people are guided most by somethign like my Rule 1, but I would be really interested in other people's collecting 'rules' and specifically.....give me some arguments to help me convince myself that 'quartz is OK' .........so that I can buy a G-2!

MarkJnK
3T WIS


Joined: Sun Apr 15th, 2007
Location: Ontario Canada
Posts: 275
Status: 
Offline
srh_pres wrote: Great shot of the G-2 Mark...hand6.gif

MarkJnK wrote:
Soooooo mjl4321, did you order the G-2 before the coupon disappears?

Just to tease you again...


Not my shot, borrowed from the O7 forum.  Sorry, forgot to mention that.

MarkJnK
3T WIS


Joined: Sun Apr 15th, 2007
Location: Ontario Canada
Posts: 275
Status: 
Offline
mjl4321 wrote: Where's the coupon?  Couldn't see it.

Might be tricky since I just told my wife about the Blue Monstrum and PloProf pre-orders ;-)

But a coupon....now that would help.

Mike


MarkJnK wrote: Soooooo mjl4321, did you order the G-2 before the coupon disappears?

Just to tease you again...


 

Here you go... it is in this thread. There are some "rules" that go along with using the coupon. http://forums.watchuseek.com/showthread.php?t=76895

Paxman
3T WIS


Joined: Sun Apr 23rd, 2006
Location: NorthEastern, Wisconsin USA
Posts: 15957
Status: 
Offline
Great read here...

I agree with CJ in that life has too many bloody rules already. As others have stated, buy what you like and can afford.

I have preferences which I am sure will change over time.

I prefer and auto/mechanical watch.

I prefer sapphire crystals.

Other than that almost anything can catch my attention. I had a heavy predilection for divers but I have seen that change over the last year...

I could care less what others thing of my watch(es) as long as I enjoy them...

EricAldovino
Guest
 

Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 
Status: 
Offline
no quartz ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Lead Theme By: Di @ UltraBB
UltraBB 1.17 Copyright © 2007-2012 Data 1 Systems
Page processed in 0.1580 seconds (42% database + 58% PHP). 54 queries executed.